Home arrow Special Reps arrow Higher Ed

Your CMEA Bay Section Special Representative for Higher Education is:

Diana Hollinger


School of Music and Dance

San Jose State University
One Washington Square
San Jose, CA 95192-0095
E-mail: Diana.Hollinger@sjsu.edu.


Higher Ed Notes March 2008

Joy and Music: Music is Joy 乐
I recently discovered that the Chinese character for music is the same used for joy: 乐
A graduate student taught me this symbol, responding to my request to learn some simple characters. “I have an easy word for you!” she assured me, smiling broadly, “and this is a good one.” She wrote it quickly and elegantly. “This is the simple Chinese symbol for music and for happiness. It is the same symbol.”
I was stunned by her matter-of-fact pronouncement. What a profound thought, that the figure for music and joy should be one. How is it I had never heard this?
Once she laughingly convinced me, I awkwardly copied her graceful strokes. I then checked with a Chinese-American colleague, who assured me it was true. “Yep,” she confirmed, “this is why I tell my students they can’t play and mope. Music is joy”
This unpretentious icon can mean yue, music, or le, happy or happiness, cheer, laughter, joy. While I know this is a naive explanation of a subtle and complex language (I beg forgiveness upfront of any Chinese-speaking readers), I still find it a poignant discovery.
According to Groves, Chinese musical scholarship is both ancient, and
interconnected to established society. In Confucian writing, “comprehensive theories of music philosophy and pitch systems evolved. These theories served to establish the principles of a ‘refined music’ (yayue), believed to reinforce state-sanctioned norms of behavior and, through regulation of pitch systems, reconcile the empire with the cosmological order” (Trasher, 2007). This was considered so important, governments established offices of “yuefu” to oversee this activity, and the Confucian Gujin tushu jicheng lists music under both “art and science” and “politics.” Bringing all things into harmony is central to Chinese thought. The “ethos” or philosophy of music (yuelun) centered on this theme. Music (yue) was regarded as an instrument, or path to this state of accord, an idea most of us are familiar with through the study of ancient Greek writings.
So, why did I find this simple thought so profound? For my entire teaching career, a large part of our professional energy has been devoted to advocacy. Music is good because
___________ . Fill in the blank. Students do better in math, English, interpersonal skills, intrapersonal skills. Or finally (and better, we realized, because other activities might achieve these extra-musical results as easily as music), because music is an intricate part of what makes us human.
MENC wrote that, “anthropologists have found no society anywhere that functions without music” (1974). Every music education student now writes a philosophy statement, and this is generally a standard job interview question. Most philosophy statements also tend to be advocacy statements of some sort. While as a profession we have moved from “put a horn in his hand, not a gun” toward recognizing the intrinsic benefits of music education, we are still in a constant state of advocacy, which is a defensive position. I think we should take a more confident stand.
A superior explanation for why we study music is set forth by Samuel Hope in the MENC Housewright collection. He states that music is not only “hardwired into our basic mental, emotional, and intellectual equipment,” but is also one of the five ways that human beings communicate with each other:
When we put letters and words together, we have language. When we put numbers and symbols together, we have mathematics. When we work to create still images, we produce the work in the fine arts, architecture, and design. When we work with the moving image, we produce dance and film. When we work with abstract sound, we create music (Hope, 2000).

Hope identifies the essential human need to create and share music, a better rationale for music education than any extra-musical reasons we can list. However, as children we discovered an even more fundamental reason for the study of music, and it is simply this: music is joy. 乐

Sources Cited:
Hope, S. (2000). “Why Study Music?” in Vision 2020. MENC: Reston, VA.
MENC, (1974).The School Music Program: Description & Standards, Music Education National Conference, Reston, VA.
Thrasher, A.R. (2007). “China,” Grove Music Online ed. L Macy (Accessed [25, January, 2008]), http://www.grovemusic.com.

 
Higher Education Notes November 2007

This is the Tempo issue when we draw your attention to some of the exciting sessions planned for the winter conference. As always, it promises to be a fabulous event, with outstanding sessions and ensembles, wonderful clinicians, and multiple opportunities to hone your skills and fellowship with colleagues. I hope you all plan to attend, as it is important for you as a teacher to take time for yourself to learn, to reconnect with each other, and to leave feeling refreshed.


Our 2008 conference is filled with an array of opportunities. As more collegiate members are beginning to attend this even, there are two sessions aimed directly at them. The first, a Collegiate Lunch and Conversation is open to all collegiate members, and will feature a roundtable conversation about current issues in music education. Pizza and drinks will be provided. This is an excellent occasion for collegiate members to get to know one another and begin networking. A second session, focused on the philosophy of music education, will feature current collegiate music education students. This session, entitled, Why Study Music? will be a panel discussion regarding the importance of music education. All years of teaching experience—novice to expert—are encouraged and welcomed, and this is an excellent forum for experienced teachers and future teachers to interact and learn from each other.


For those of you more interested in concrete material, something you can use right away, Dr. Janet Averett, San Jose State University clarinet instructor and orchestra conductor humorously presents, How to Play Clarinet Badly . . . and What Else Did You Want to Know? Providing tips for teaching clarinet within the ensemble setting, and how to get a better sound from your clarinet section, she answers all those pesky questions: Why do they SOUND like that? What kind of reed is that? Why can’t they play that note in tune? —and much more! This session is a must for all instrumental teachers, from elementary through high school.


If you have ever wondered why it is we teach what and how we do, then don’t miss Where Do We Come From? Historical Connections in Music Education. Professor Gordon Haramaki and myself (professors of history and music education at San Jose State University) provide a context for current music education trends. Ever wonder why we teach band, choir, and orchestra instead of something else? Not sure where the band really came from? What about jazz band and marching band? What social influences shaped music education and continue to drive us? In this session you will learn historical context for your ensemble settings and how music education developed within American public schools, so you can better address historical and cultural standards in the classroom.


Finally, for those of you hoping to expand the cultural boundaries of your music classrooms, come to Tracing and Teaching Latin American Rhythms, presented by Professor Abi Ramirez from San Jose State University, formerly from University of the Andes in Mérida, Venezuela. In a lively and interactive presentation, Professor Ramirez will discuss the development of basic rhythmic patterns of Brazil, Argentina, and Cuba, and how you can teach them and use them in your classroom.


I hope to see you all in January. Good luck in your school year.

 
Higher Education Notes September 2007

tower_2.jpgDuring 2006–2007 the SJSU School of Music piloted “The San José Music Project,” designed to address some of the problems facing music education in California public schools. Using music education majors from San José State University, we infused resources into local music programs and provided future teachers with experience, academic credit, and scholarships. Th e SJSU Music Project is a joint venture between the California Music Project, (founded in November of 2004 with start-up funds from the California Arts Council), and SJSU, and is an eff ort to tackle issues at each level of music education.

As most of us know, California’s current music education problems are multi-faceted, grounded in the passage of Proposition 13 in the late 1970s, and fueled by state budgetary problems and new assessment priorities brought about by No Child Left Behind legislation. With fewer students coming through our public school music programs, we produced fewer music teachers; schools now fi nd it diffi cult to staff music programs, and current teachers are often stretched to cover more than they should. Prolonged advocacy eff orts over the last several years have resulted in statistical resources documenting some of these changes, including National Association for Music Education website (menc.org), National Association of Music Merchants (namm.org), Support Music, sponsored by NAMM and MENC (supportmusic.com), and the Music for All Foundation (musicforall.org), where we can stay abreast of recent developments. Student involvement within California public school music programs has declined, and according to 2004 fi gures from Th e Sound of Silence, though student populations have increased since 1999, the percentage of public school students involved in music education courses declined by 50%, and the number of music teachers declined by 26%.

The San José Music Project strives to address these declines. Acknowledging that existing programs may be struggling, the Project attempts to provide expanded resources to current students and teachers. Recognizing that our current pool of teachers is not adequate, the Project endeavors to identify and nurture future music teachers, providing monetary resources, professional experience, and academic credit. Understanding that the field of music education needs future leaders, the Project employs a graduate assistant who helps to oversee the program and off ers support to fellowship students, allowing bright young music educators the opportunity to develop leadership skills. Finally, by fostering community around the University, the Program creates a synergy that produces greater results for the invested resources than might occur using more fragmented eff orts.

Thus, through one inclusive program, the SJMP attempts to address the California music education losses at all levels. Th e SJMP is funded and administered through a unique collaboration among the California Music Project, the SJSU School of Music and Dance, the SJSU Associated Students, and the SJSU Cesar Chavez Action Center. During the pilot year, ten “fellowships” were awarded to potential music educators from SJSU who worked eight to ten hours weekly for fi fteen weeks each semester in local public schools. Each student earned $4500 toward educational expenses, and received academic credit while getting hands-on experience in real-life educational settings. A graduate assistant helped administer the program, earning a stipend and graduate academic credit, while developing leadership skills. The entire program is overseen by the Department of Music Education, creating and strengthening ties between the University and the community. This year, over $50,000 was distributed to ten fellowship students and one graduate assistant. They assisted music teachers in 17 local public schools, elementary through high school. During the 2007-2008 school year, we plan to expand to fourteen fellowship students and one graduate student; a total of fifteen students.

It is our intent to address the attrition rate of music educators, the feeling of isolation and overwork that many music teachers feel, the lack of a sense of “professional respect” within the fi eld itself, and a genuine need for teaching resources within current music classrooms. We hope to create a growing community around the University that will improve and expand over time. By offering “fellowships” to promising music education students, we hope to suggest to them that theirs is a professional fi eld which they should enter with pride and consider a lifetime career. By sending them to assist current music teachers, we hope to breathe life and energy into existing programs. By placing a graduate assistant in a support position, we hope to train leaders for our future. The fellowships are never to be used for afterschool programs or to supplant qualifi ed music teachers. In order to combat this trend, fellowship students can only be placed with existing credentialed music teachers so that school administrators will not see this as an alternative to hiring music teachers. Students assist with teaching and administrative duties, teaching classes, leading sectionals, teaching private and group lessons, and in concerts and after-school activities. Both music teachers and fellowship students were extremely positive about the SJMP during the pilot year.

One of the things that made the SJMP possible was a unique collaboration of an educational institution and a non-profi t organization with a diversifi ed board of directors. I have served on many boards over the last few years, and have been delighted to do so. However, the general make-up of these boards is usually other music educators. I frequently serve with many of the same fi ne individuals, most of us with similar backgrounds. CMP brings together people from business, the music industry, development, government, and music education. Th is wide range of experience helps us bring new ideas and resources together for one of the most unique opportunities for change I have seen during my career. In the past I have been frustrated because music education boards do not have the monetary access to eff ect real change and discouraged when I have seen monetary resources wasted because music educators were not part of decision-making processes. CMP is an eff ort to bring together the experiential, intellectual, and monetary resources that have often worked apart from each other. Th is unique collaboration promises new and diff erent approaches to change. You have only to look at the makeup of the CMP board to see the wide range of backgrounds of those involved.

We are extraordinarily optimistic after this pilot year, and look forward to making improvements as we go into the next year of the San José Music Project. Th e eventual aim of the Project is to spread to other CSU campuses, addressing the music education problems throughout the state and creating communities of support. It is my hope that in ten years we will see a significant difference in the attrition rate of current teachers, a growth in the population of future teachers, an expansion of music education to greater serve our public school students, a sense of community between university and area schools, and a greater sense of pride and purpose within our field—all sprouting from one simple idea; that by identifying the areas of need and investing our resources to address the fundamental sources of our crisis, we will produce long-term, systemic change.

For more information regarding the California Music Project and our program here at San José State University, go to the CMP website at www.californiamusicproject. com/ or the CAC website at www.cac.ca.gov, and for specifi c SJMP information, go to my faculty website and follow the links at www. sjsu.edu/faculty_and_staff/faculty_detail. jsp?id=1980. To receive an application for a fellowship student, feel free to contact me directly. We are excited to begin our second year of the San José Music Project, and we hope to be a resource to those of you teaching in surrounding communities. I wish each and every one of you a wonderful school year! 

 
Higher Education Notes May, 2007

The Importance of Good Models in Music Teaching, or "Show Me, Don't Tell Me"

Over the last several years,

Read more...
 
Higher Ed Student Report

A Recipe for a Successful Lesson Plan by Lee Tian-Tee,

Jamie A. Bruno & Thomas A. Edwards

In our teaching experience we have learned that good lesson planning can be challenging. There are many different ways to approach lesson planning, which sometimes seems tedious. One way we have made lesson planning a more motivating and successful experience is to think of planning a good lesson like planning a good meal.

Read more...
 

Bay Section News